Print Advertising News, Interviews and More
Blog Posts > Posts tagged "results"

News Corp. To Pay Valassis $500 million to Settle Antitrust Charges

Posted on February 01, 2010 by Mediabids

 

 From YahooNews. Full story here

LIVONIA, Mich. – News Corp. subsidiary News America Marketing has agreed to pay rival Valassis Communications Inc. $500 million to settle antitrust charges.

Valassis, a marketing company that provides direct mail and coupons, said the deal settles lawsuits it filed in several states against News America Marketing. Among them is a jury decision in Michigan circuit court last July that awarded Valassis $300 million in damages. News America was appealing that ruling.

Valassis accused News America of threatening customers with price hikes for not offering exclusivity in marketing deals.

Meanwhile, News America argued that Valassis tried to force higher marketing rates by publicly announcing price changes.

In a statement Saturday, News Corp. said it did not want to risk presenting the case to a jury in Michigan federal court, where it was scheduled for trial Tuesday. Citing unspecified concerns over the venue in U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Chief Operating Officer Chase Carey said News Corp. decided "it was in the best interests of the company and its stockholders to agree to a settlement."

Valassis said the deal also includes a 10-year shared mail distribution agreement with News America.

Newspaper and Magazine Ads Tops For Bargain Hunters

Posted on February 01, 2010 by Mediabids

 Before you get too excited about this report from MediaPost, read the very last paragraph. Full story here

Bargain Hunters Start With Newspaper and Magazine Ads

 

by Jack Loechner, 2 hours ago


 












According to a recent Adweek Media/ Harris Poll, 23% of adult Americans believe that newspaper and magazine advertisements are where they can find the best bargains. 18% believe online advertisements are most likely to help them find the best bargains. 10% say direct mail and 12% catalogs, 11% television commercials, and just 2% say radio. And, 34% of Americans believe the type of ad makes no difference when they are looking for the best bargain.

When looking for the best bargains, different age groups have different ideas of where to look:

  • 18-34 year olds are more likely to say online ads (22%) and television commercials (17%) are the best places to go
  • 35-44 year olds go online (26%)
  • 24% of those 44-54 and 33% of those 55 and older say newspaper and magazine advertisements those are media most likely to help them find the best bargain

Advertising Most Likely to Help Find Bargain - Age (Base: All U.S. adults; % of Category Respondents)

 

Age

 

Total

18-34

35-44

45-54

55+

Newspaper/Magazine advertisements

23%

15%

16%

24%

33%

Online advertisements

18

22

26

17

12

Direct mail and catalogs

12

13

13

14

10

Television commercials

11

17

12

8

7

Radio

2

2

3

< .5

1

None- the type of ad makes no difference

34

31

31

36

36

Source: Harris Polls, January 2010

Among the genders, women are more likely than men to say newspaper and magazine advertisements, and direct mail and catalogs are more likely to help them find a bargain. Men, on the other hand, are more likely to say online advertisements are more likely to help them find a bargain.

There is also an interesting educational difference in the media people believe can help them find the best bargains:

  • One-quarter of those with a high school education or less say newspaper and magazine advertisements are more likely to help them find a bargain, compared to 20% of those with at least a college degree.
  • 29% with at least a college degree believe online advertisements are more likely to help them find a bargain compared to 12% of those with a high school education or less

Advertising Most Likely to Help Find Bargain - Gender & Education (Base: All U.S. adults; % of Category Respondents)

 

 

Gender

Education

 

Total

Men

Women

HS or less

Some college

College grad

Newspaper/Magazine advertisements

23%

22%

24%

25%

23%

20%

Online advertisements

18

21

16

12

18

29

Direct mail and catalogs

12

11

14

12

12

12

Television commercials

11

12

10

12

12

8

Radio

2

2

1

3

1

1

None- the type of ad makes no difference

34

32

35

36

33

31

Source: Harris Polls, January 2010

The report concludes that, while newspaper ads are still slightly ahead of others among all adults when it comes to bargain hunting, online is not far behind. And, online ads lead newspaper and magazine ads, as a source of information about bargains, among younger, better educated consumers, who are much more attractive to most advertisers.

AdAge: Advertising Will Change Forever, the Digital Age is Upon Us

Posted on July 21, 2009 by Mediabids

 

If you are involved in the print industry, representing a newspaper or magazine, you have read these types of articles before - the digital age is upon us. Ink is doomed. Whether or not you believe it, there is no denying the trend towards the digital. Josh Bernoff, synopsizes the digital-is-our-future argument well, in his story in this week's AdAge. He might disagree but what I think he is really saying has less to do with how the advertising is presented and in what medium and more to do with the fact that advertisers want results- measurable, verifiable, results. Digital advertising is ready made to measure response. But it can be done in print. At Mediabids, we measure the results of thousands of ads and when measured, newspapers and magazines generate very respectable results, oftentimes outperforming digital from an ROI perspective. So, Bernoff may be wrong about the speed of the gravitational pull toward digital, but he is right about why digital is so appealing to so many advertisers right now.

Here is a portion of Bernoff's story:

In this recession, marketers have learned that interactive marketing is more effective, and advertising less effective, per dollar spent. While budgets for online have decreased, they decreased less than other budgets. Six out of ten marketers we surveyed agreed with the statement "we will increase budget for interactive by shifting money away from traditional marketing." Only 7% said "we have no plans to increase our marketing budget."

Unlike the last recession, digital marketing is no longer experimental. Now it looks more like advertising is inefficient, relative to digital. More than half of the marketers we surveyed said that effectiveness of direct mail, TV, magazines, outdoor, newspapers, and radio would stay the same or decrease within three years. In contrast, well over 70% expected the effectiveness of channels like created social media, online video, and mobile marketing to increase.

The result is that digital, which will be about 12% of overall advertising spend in 2009, is likely to grow to about 21% in five years. Along the way overall advertising budgets won't grow much.

Even Brand Advertisers Like Results

Posted on July 15, 2009 by Mediabids

As a follow up to our diatribe yesterday on BusinessWeek consider this typically snarky comment from AdAge:

"Why the persistent drop for the business bibles? Business-to-business advertisers have found many more efficient, targeted ways to reach their customers. Brand campaigns remain an important component of their marketing, but they've also gotten much better at maintaining databases of the crucial decision makers who buy their products or services, focusing on preserving their loyalty and contacting them more or less directly than through a major magazine ad buy."

If you are in print - newspapers or magazines - this comment should really bug you. The author, Nat Ives, is wrong about the potential for print publications to generate response for non-branding campaigns but he is expressing a sentiment which is common in the advertising world. In other words, the advertisers you covet think he is right about magazines being a branding advertising medium. Further proof, that if print publications don't start proving response to their customers using any number of rudimentary tracking mechanisms (800#s, text addresses, unique urls), no one will.


Survey Says: Newspaper Ads Second Most Helpful, Web Banners Least Helpful

Posted on July 02, 2009 by Mediabids

Newspaper ads placed second in a Harris Interactive, AdWeekMedia, survey of most helpful ads by medium. Full story here.

Banner ads ranked last as the most ignored type of advertising.

The results of this survey are particularly surprising when you consider what a similar survey would look like if advertisers were polled. My guess would be (this is only a guess, a quick search for a similar survey didn't yield any results but I will keep looking) that advertisers would rank the effectiveness of mediums quite differently.Which means that advertisers don't really know what is really working.

Online advertising has response measurements built in- anyone can see how many clicks or views they have received. Newspapers and magazines have done a lousy job introducing similar measurement metrics. So, despite the fact that readers say newspaper ads are extremely valuable when determining future purchases, advertisers don't know it. The scary part is- neither do publications.

You want to know why newspapers' advertising revenues are down more than other mediums? Readership and competition are no doubt issues but the big one and the one that print publications can directly control is that advertisers do not see the value in the medium. If people in the print industry don't show them, who will? Please note: I said show, not tell. Print publications generate results but advertisers don't consider the tracking of results to be their job, newspapers and magazines have to do that job themselves.

At Mediabids, we have taken this approach, in many instances, for the past 3 years and it works. Advertisers still buy print when you can show them it works.